Best Ice Cream in Indianapolis: 5 Local Scoop Shops

What is the least popular ice cream?

Indy has a sweet tooth. These five local shops earn some of the city’s best reviews for frozen treats.

  • Nicey Treat (Broad Ripple): known for its Nicey Pops and frozen treats.
  • Chris’ Ice Cream (Northside): a classic walk-up stand.
  • Square Scoop (Fountain Square): a popular stop on Virginia Avenue.
  • LiftOff Creamery (Herron-Morton): a neighborhood ice cream shop with strong reviews.
  • Brics (Broad Ripple): ice cream right on the Monon Trail.

Picks are based on recent reviews as of November 2026. Many shops have seasonal hours, so check before you go.