After a hailstorm, Indy fills up with out-of-town crews knocking on doors. These are five locally owned roofing companies with Indianapolis addresses, years of local reviews and A+ BBB ratings. We read the recent reviews for each and wrote down what people actually say.
Our 5 picks at a glance
- Raptor Roofing: photo updates during the job
- Indy Rooftops: insurance claims
- Indy Roof & Restoration: roof and gutter replacement together
- WaterTight Roofing & Exteriors: repairs and leaks
- Coomer Roofing Company: older and historic homes
Nobody paid to be on this list. We picked and ordered these businesses using the method below. Some local businesses pay to be the labeled expert behind one of our guides. If one of them is on this list, it gets an “Expert partner (paid)” badge, and it never moves up because of it.
1. Raptor Roofing
Best for photo updates during the job
What reviewers say: Reviewers highlight thorough inspections, hands-on help dealing with insurance adjusters, and clear communication with photos while the work is happening. Roof replacements, gutters, siding and windows all come up, and many mention one-day installs and spotless cleanup.
- Independent Indiana company, in business since 2021 (BBB); formerly Raptor Restoration
- Roof repair and replacement, storm inspections, gutters, siding, windows
- South side (S Meridian St), serving Indianapolis and Central Indiana
2. Indy Rooftops
Best for insurance claims
What reviewers say: Reviewers repeatedly credit the reps with walking them through long, difficult insurance claims until a full replacement was approved. Crews are described as fast and tidy, with no nails left in the yard, and the person who quoted the job stays involved through the install.
- Locally owned Indianapolis company, in business since about 2022 (BBB)
- Roof replacement and repair, inspections, leak repair, flat roofs, gutters, siding, soffit and fascia (BBB)
- West side (N Raceway Rd)
3. Indy Roof & Restoration
Best for roof and gutter replacement together
What reviewers say: Reviewers praise help with insurance claims, clear communication from a single project contact, and crews that finish in a day and clean up well. Roof-and-gutter replacements and storm or tree damage repairs come up often, and several mention honest, no-pressure assessments.
- Founded in 2018 (its website and BBB)
- Roofing, gutters and guards, storm damage repair
- South side (Elmwood Ave), serving Central Indiana
4. WaterTight Roofing & Exteriors
Best for repairs and leaks
What reviewers say: Reviewers praise a hands-on owner who explains repairs with photos, prices that beat other bids, and quick turnaround on leaks, gutters, fascia and siding. Several mention a workmanship warranty and the company coming back years later to fix something at no charge.
Good to know: It mostly does repairs and exterior work rather than big full replacements.
- Small owner-run business, according to reviewers
- Roof repairs, leaks, gutters, fascia and soffit, siding
- West side (W Washington St)
5. Coomer Roofing Company
Best for older and historic homes
What reviewers say: Reviewers keep naming the same contacts for fast quotes, fair prices and no-pressure advice. They praise Coomer for fixing leaks other roofers missed, flat and balcony roofs, gutters with leaf screens, and careful work in historic neighborhoods.
- Family-owned, BBB accredited since 1986; its website says 70 years in business
- Residential roofing, flat roofs, gutters and leaf screens, siding repair
- South side (S Harding St), serving Indianapolis and Central Indiana
How we picked
- We started with roofing companies that show up on Google Maps for Indianapolis searches and have an Indianapolis address.
- To make the list, a company had to be locally owned (no national franchises or out-of-state storm crews), rated 4.8 or higher on Google with at least 100 reviews, and rated A+ by the BBB. We left off one company with offices in other Indiana cities until we can confirm its ownership.
- We ordered them by Google rating adjusted for review count, so a 4.9 from 1,000 people counts for more than a 5.0 from 12. (We blend each rating with 100 reviews at 4.5 stars, so small samples don’t jump to the top.)
- We read about 25 Google reviews for each company and summarized the themes that came up more than once. One-off complaints aren’t counted as themes.
- Ratings and review counts were checked on November 14, 2026. They change daily, so click through for today’s numbers. We recheck this list every few months.
Before you hire a roofer
- Be careful with door-knockers after a storm. Ask for a local address and look them up before you sign anything.
- Indiana doesn’t issue a statewide roofing license, so ask for proof of liability insurance and workers’ comp instead.
- Never sign over your insurance check or pay the full price up front. A reasonable deposit is normal; the rest is due when the job is done.
- Get the scope in writing: tear-off or overlay, underlayment, flashing, vents, and who hauls away the old roof.
- Ask about two warranties: the manufacturer’s warranty on the shingles and the roofer’s own workmanship warranty.
Questions people ask
Will my insurance pay for a new roof after hail?
Often, if the damage is from a covered storm and you file in time. A good roofer will inspect, photograph the damage and meet your adjuster, but the decision is your insurance company’s.
How long does a roof replacement take?
Most homes on this list were done in a single day, according to reviewers. Bigger or more complex roofs can take two or three.
Why isn’t my roofer on the list?
It may not have met one of our cutoffs (4.8+ on Google with 100+ reviews, A+ BBB, locally owned with an Indianapolis address), or we may have missed it. Tell us about it using the link below, and we’ll look at it when we recheck the list.
Run a roofing company in Indianapolis? Tell us about your business. Getting on this list is free and follows the rules above. Separately, you can become the labeled local expert behind one of our guides.